Opening Evidence Law: Opinion Evidence
Evidence Law: Opinion Evidence
- Length
- 31 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- CQUniversity2014
Chapter 1 of 5: Before the lecture
Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible, and Marinac's session 11 of the CQUniversity Evidence Law course sets out the exceptions. He starts from the line between observation and interpretation, citing Cross on Evidence and Lithgow City Council v Jackson. Lay opinion survives only where a witness needs it to convey ordinary observations such as speed or sobriety. Expert opinion requires a recognised body of knowledge under R v Bonython, with Osland v R and R v Harris testing who counts as an expert. Makita v Sproules, the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules on written reports, and the handling of conflicting experts complete the treatment, which assumes earlier weeks.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Applies the Bonython test and Makita v Sproules to decide when expert opinion evidence is admissible.
Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible, and Marinac's session 11 of the CQUniversity Evidence Law course sets out the exceptions. He starts from the line between observation and interpretation, citing Cross on Evidence and Lithgow City Council v Jackson. Lay opinion survives only where a witness needs it to convey ordinary observations such as speed or sobriety. Expert opinion requires a recognised body of knowledge under R v Bonython, with Osland v R and R v Harris testing who counts as an expert. Makita v Sproules, the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules on written reports, and the handling of conflicting experts complete the treatment, which assumes earlier weeks.
Cross on Evidence
Lithgow City Council v Jackson [2011] HCA 36
Buckley v Thomas (1554) 75 ER 182
R v Bonython (1984) 15 A.Crim.R 364
Osland v R (1998) 197 CLR 316
R v Harris (1997) 7 NTLR 1
Makita v Sproules [2001] NSWCA 305
R v Ryan [2002] VSCA 176
R v Tonkin [1975] Qd R 1
Chamberlain v R (No. 2) (1984) 153 CLR 521
Murphy v R (1989) 167 CLR 94
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (1999)
This lecture
Lecture 11 of 11 of Evidence Law.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.