Opening 'Principle and Pragmatism in Public Law': The 2019 Sir David Williams Lecture
'Principle and Pragmatism in Public Law': The 2019 Sir David Williams Lecture
- Length
- 45 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- University of Cambridge2019
Chapter 1 of 5: Before the lecture
Judicial review in English public law balances legal principle against pragmatic judgment, and Baroness Hale tests that balance in the 2019 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge. Starting from Patrick Atiyah's Hamlyn lectures, Pragmatism and Theory in English Law, she takes three doctrines in turn. Deference, read through Lord Hoffmann in Pro Life Alliance and Lord Sumption in Lord Carlile, emerges as respect for executive expertise and evidence. Legitimate expectation rests on fairness and good administration. The principle of legality demands clear statutory words before fundamental rights yield, alongside declarations of incompatibility under section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Hale grounds judicial deference in executive competence, not democratic legitimacy, citing Pro Life Alliance.
Judicial review in English public law balances legal principle against pragmatic judgment, and Baroness Hale tests that balance in the 2019 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge. Starting from Patrick Atiyah's Hamlyn lectures, Pragmatism and Theory in English Law, she takes three doctrines in turn. Deference, read through Lord Hoffmann in Pro Life Alliance and Lord Sumption in Lord Carlile, emerges as respect for executive expertise and evidence. Legitimate expectation rests on fairness and good administration. The principle of legality demands clear statutory words before fundamental rights yield, alongside declarations of incompatibility under section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998.
Not in the Public Interest
Keeping the Peace
Sex Disqualification Removal Act
Pragmatism and Theory in English Law
Pro Life Alliance case
Lord Carlile case
Professor Jowell's 2003 article
Nicklinson case
Haas, Koch, and Gross
Pretty v the United Kingdom
Microcosmographica Academica
Belmarsh case
Re G
Finacane case
Unison case
Evans case
Ahmed and Her Majesty's Treasury
United Nations Act 1946
This lecture
Talk 4 of 16 of The Sir David Williams Lectures.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.