Opening The Rule of Law as the Rule of Common Right and Reason
The Rule of Law as the Rule of Common Right and Reason
- Length
- 57 min
- Level
- Graduate
- Recorded
- University of Cambridge2025
Chapter 1 of 8: Before the lecture
The rule of law, Trevor Allan argues in the 2025 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge, makes the choice between parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy a false one. Allan starts from Coke's claim in Bonham's Case that acts against common right and reason are void at common law. On his account, the rule of law holds only where no unregulated pocket of arbitrary power exists, so every coercive act needs a legal justification. Ouster clauses, Anisminic, Evans and Lord Hoffman's principle of legality in Sims are read as reasoned interpretation rather than disobedience. Historical dissents against arbitrary detention support the claim that an unjust statute is a contradiction in terms, and that the judicial review debate is largely misconceived.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Reads Bonham's case through to the control order rulings as reasoned interpretation, not judicial defiance of statute.
The rule of law, Trevor Allan argues in the 2025 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge, makes the choice between parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy a false one. Allan starts from Coke's claim in Bonham's Case that acts against common right and reason are void at common law. On his account, the rule of law holds only where no unregulated pocket of arbitrary power exists, so every coercive act needs a legal justification. Ouster clauses, Anisminic, Evans and Lord Hoffman's principle of legality in Sims are read as reasoned interpretation rather than disobedience. Historical dissents against arbitrary detention support the claim that an unjust statute is a contradiction in terms, and that the judicial review debate is largely misconceived.
Law, Liberty and Justice
Constitutional Justice
The Sovereignty of Law
Report on the Constitution
Privacy International
Sims
Bonham's Case
Cooper and Wandsworth Board of Works
Evans
Simms
Anisminic
Dr. Bonham's Case
Bollom's case
AF number three (2010)
Prevention of Terrorism Act
Human Rights Act, Section 3
King against Holliday, Ex parte Zadig (1917)
Defense of the Realm Act 1914
Liversidge and Anderson (1942)
European Convention, Article 15
CLJ 2012 volume
This lecture
Talk 16 of 16 of The Sir David Williams Lectures.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.