Opening 'Judicial review of discretionary decision-making: Differences of approach'
'Judicial review of discretionary decision-making: Differences of approach'
- Length
- 53 min
- Level
- Graduate
- Recorded
- University of Cambridge2024
Chapter 1 of 8: Before the lecture
Judicial review of administrative discretion has taken different paths in the United Kingdom and Australia, and Kiefel traces why. She starts from the early common law rule that discretionary power must be exercised within the rule of reason, as stated in Rook's case. The Wednesbury decision then narrowed reasonableness to irrationality, before UK courts adopted a sliding scale of review and proportionality where fundamental rights are affected. Australian courts instead tie lawfulness to the scope and purpose of the governing statute. Kiefel reads recent High Court authority on unreasonableness as a lack of intelligible justification, and links the law–merits dichotomy to Australia's written constitution and separation of powers.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Kiefel sets the UK's proportionality and sliding scale of review against Australia's strict law–merits divide.
Judicial review of administrative discretion has taken different paths in the United Kingdom and Australia, and Kiefel traces why. She starts from the early common law rule that discretionary power must be exercised within the rule of reason, as stated in Rook's case. The Wednesbury decision then narrowed reasonableness to irrationality, before UK courts adopted a sliding scale of review and proportionality where fundamental rights are affected. Australian courts instead tie lawfulness to the scope and purpose of the governing statute. Kiefel reads recent High Court authority on unreasonableness as a lack of intelligible justification, and links the law–merits dichotomy to Australia's written constitution and separation of powers.
Rooke's Case
Sharp v Wakefield
Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation
Sunday Entertainments Act 1932
Smith
Fam
Klein and Domas
Administrative Decisions Judicial Review Act 1977 Commonwealth
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs and Pica Wolfcent
Attorney-General of New South Wales and Quinn
Chan and Minister for Immigration
Minister for Immigration against Lee
This lecture
Talk 1 of 16 of The Sir David Williams Lectures.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.