Opening 'The Craft of Constitutional Adjudication': The 2023 Sir David Williams Lecture
'The Craft of Constitutional Adjudication': The 2023 Sir David Williams Lecture
- Length
- 51 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- University of Cambridge2023
Chapter 1 of 7: Before the lecture
O'Regan applies Carl Llewellyn's account of judging as a craft to South Africa's post-apartheid Constitutional Court.
Constitutional adjudication has grown as written constitutions in over 160 countries let courts review legislation against fundamental rights. In the 2023 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge, O'Regan sorts these new judicial powers into five categories. She then takes up Carl Llewellyn's account of appellate judging as a craft resting on individual skill and shared tradition. The formal style, bound to literal text, is set against the grand style, which reasons from purpose, history and principle toward reasonable predictability. South Africa's transition from apartheid supplies the main case, followed by the contests over legitimacy that shifts in reasoning style provoke among judges and scholars.
Constitutional adjudication has grown as written constitutions in over 160 countries let courts review legislation against fundamental rights. In the 2023 Sir David Williams Lecture at Cambridge, O'Regan sorts these new judicial powers into five categories. She then takes up Carl Llewellyn's account of appellate judging as a craft resting on individual skill and shared tradition. The formal style, bound to literal text, is set against the grand style, which reasons from purpose, history and principle toward reasonable predictability. South Africa's transition from apartheid supplies the main case, followed by the contests over legitimacy that shifts in reasoning style provoke among judges and scholars.
Against Constitutionalism
The Common Law Tradition: Deciding Appeals
Ridge v. Baldwin
Dear Comrade President
The Longest Erratum Note in History
Please sir, may we have some more literalism?

This lecture
Talk 2 of 16 of The Sir David Williams Lectures.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.
Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in