Opening John Locke on Personal Identity
John Locke on Personal Identity
- Length
- 15 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- University of Oxford2011
Chapter 1 of 4: Criteria of identity for matter
John Locke's account of personal identity holds that the criterion for sameness over time depends on what kind of thing is in question. Millican starts with single corpuscles and bodies of matter, asking whether a lump of clay survives the gradual loss of particles. The Sorites paradox, with reference to Timothy Williamson's work on vagueness, shows how hard precise boundaries are to draw. Plants and animals, by contrast, persist through a continuous history of organised life. A person, a thinking intelligent being with reason and reflection, persists through continuity of consciousness. Locke argues that an immaterial soul fails as a criterion because of its obscurity and possible turnover.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Millican follows Locke from atoms and lumps of clay to organisms, then persons as continuous consciousness.
John Locke's account of personal identity holds that the criterion for sameness over time depends on what kind of thing is in question. Millican starts with single corpuscles and bodies of matter, asking whether a lump of clay survives the gradual loss of particles. The Sorites paradox, with reference to Timothy Williamson's work on vagueness, shows how hard precise boundaries are to draw. Plants and animals, by contrast, persist through a continuous history of organised life. A person, a thinking intelligent being with reason and reflection, persists through continuity of consciousness. Locke argues that an immaterial soul fails as a criterion because of its obscurity and possible turnover.
This lecture
Lecture 21 of 23 of Oxford Philosophy: General Philosophy.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.