Opening Problems for Locke's View of Personal Identity
Problems for Locke's View of Personal Identity
- Length
- 10 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- University of Oxford2011
Chapter 1 of 3: Locke's view and Reid's problem
Locke's memory criterion of personal identity, from the Essay Concerning Human Understanding, faces Thomas Reid's brave officer objection. Millican sets out how the case breaks the transitivity of identity: the general remembers the officer, the officer the boy, yet the general not the boy. The repair defines an ancestral relation on memory recursively, on the model of ancestry built from parenthood, so overlapping chains link indirect experiences. Quasi-memory then replaces genuine memory to keep the criterion from circularity. Dreamless sleep, comas and Descartes on continuous thinking suggest that bodily or brain continuity must bridge the gaps in consciousness.
Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Repairs Locke's memory criterion against Reid's brave officer case by defining an ancestral relation on memory.
Locke's memory criterion of personal identity, from the Essay Concerning Human Understanding, faces Thomas Reid's brave officer objection. Millican sets out how the case breaks the transitivity of identity: the general remembers the officer, the officer the boy, yet the general not the boy. The repair defines an ancestral relation on memory recursively, on the model of ancestry built from parenthood, so overlapping chains link indirect experiences. Quasi-memory then replaces genuine memory to keep the criterion from circularity. Dreamless sleep, comas and Descartes on continuous thinking suggest that bodily or brain continuity must bridge the gaps in consciousness.
This lecture
Lecture 22 of 23 of Oxford Philosophy: General Philosophy.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.