Opening Persons, Humans and Brains
Persons, Humans and Brains
- Length
- 11 min
- Level
- Introductory
- Recorded
- University of Oxford2011
Chapter 1 of 3: Persons and organisms
Personal identity theory asks whether a person is a human organism, a brain, or something else. Millican first collapses the distinction between person and animal, which makes personhood an accidental rather than a necessary property of the organism. Identifying persons with developed, functioning brains handles brain transplants but breaks down in split-brain cases. These puzzles support Derek Parfit's view that identity is a matter of degree, grounded in psychological and brain continuity. Friedrich Waismann's notion of open texture then explains why radically novel cases may have no correct answer. The session belongs to Millican's General Philosophy course for first-year Oxford students, recorded in late 2009.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Tests whether a person is a brain against split-brain cases, then turns to Waismann's open texture for an answer.
Personal identity theory asks whether a person is a human organism, a brain, or something else. Millican first collapses the distinction between person and animal, which makes personhood an accidental rather than a necessary property of the organism. Identifying persons with developed, functioning brains handles brain transplants but breaks down in split-brain cases. These puzzles support Derek Parfit's view that identity is a matter of degree, grounded in psychological and brain continuity. Friedrich Waismann's notion of open texture then explains why radically novel cases may have no correct answer. The session belongs to Millican's General Philosophy course for first-year Oxford students, recorded in late 2009.
This lecture
Lecture 23 of 23 of Oxford Philosophy: General Philosophy.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.