Opening Suicide, Part I: The Rationality of Suicide (Yale PHIL 176)
Suicide, Part I: The Rationality of Suicide (Yale PHIL 176)
- Length
- 45 min
- Level
- Undergraduate
- Recorded
- Yale University2008
Chapter 1 of 5: Distinguishing rationality and morality
Kagan opens the suicide sessions of Yale PHIL 176 by separating whether suicide can be rational from whether it can be morally permitted. He first tests the two-state requirement, the objection that nonexistence offers no condition against which a life could be better or worse. Rejecting that requirement, he compares hedonism with container theories of wellbeing to show how a life of enough pain can fall below the zero line. Graphs of quality of life over time then separate premature suicide during a temporary downturn from a rational choice under degenerative illness. The argument builds on the earlier sessions' treatment of wellbeing and mortality.

Your comment is kept while you sign up.Sign in
Kagan answers the two-state objection and plots life-quality curves to show when ending a life is rationally coherent.
Kagan opens the suicide sessions of Yale PHIL 176 by separating whether suicide can be rational from whether it can be morally permitted. He first tests the two-state requirement, the objection that nonexistence offers no condition against which a life could be better or worse. Rejecting that requirement, he compares hedonism with container theories of wellbeing to show how a life of enough pain can fall below the zero line. Graphs of quality of life over time then separate premature suicide during a temporary downturn from a rational choice under degenerative illness. The argument builds on the earlier sessions' treatment of wellbeing and mortality.
This lecture
Lecture 23 of 25 of Death.
Choose a node to see how it connects to this lecture. What comes before is on the leftat the top. What comes after is on the rightat the bottom. The ring is what it teaches. People and places are above. Other lectures and books are below.
Press a chosen node again to open it.